Stop being confident

CBChris Bodman24 August 2025 · 5 min read

We’ve been thinking about confidence all wrong.

It’s not binary — you don’t either have it or lack it.

Confidence operates on a continuum from low to high, and where you sit depends entirely on the situation.

Leading a team meeting? You might be at an 8/10. Presenting to the board? Maybe a 4. Coaching someone in your expertise? Back up to a 9.

This isn’t inconsistency. It’s normal. It’s human.

Notice the subtle but crucial difference between thinking I am confident versus I have confidence in this situation. The first makes it about your identity, locking you into a mindset that is rigid. The second makes it about your current state, creating space for movement and growth.

When you think you’re not a confident person, you’ve boxed yourself in. When you recognise that your confidence is simply low in this particular area, you’ve created room to move.

Confidence isn’t who you are. It’s where you are on the scale right now.

This reframe becomes even more powerful when we examine what we commonly call imposter syndrome. Let’s get the language right: it’s not a syndrome at all. You don’t have a pathological condition. You’re experiencing a phenomenon — a natural psychological response to unfamiliar territory.

The imposter phenomenon occurs when you’re operating beyond your established competence zone. It’s your brain’s way of saying we haven’t done this before, proceed with caution.

This isn’t dysfunction, it’s actually sophisticated risk assessment. Your nervous system is doing exactly what it evolved to do: alerting you to potential threats to your social standing and professional reputation.

Here’s the counterintuitive truth: if you’ve reached a place where everything feels comfortable and covered, you might actually need this imposter feeling. It’s evidence you’re stretching, growing, taking on challenges that matter.

Consider the challenge-to-skill ratio that flow researchers have mapped extensively. When your skills perfectly match the challenge, you’re in your comfort zone — safe but static. When the challenge exceeds your skills, that’s precisely where growth happens.

And that’s exactly where the imposter phenomenon shows up as your psychological GPS, telling you you’ve entered new territory.

Context shapes everything. Consider two scenarios: sitting at a dinner party versus standing on stage giving a presentation.

Same person, same day, completely different confidence levels. At the dinner party, you’re relaxed, conversational, authentic. On stage, your palms sweat and your voice shakes.

What’s different?

The challenge-to-skill ratio. The dinner party matches your well-developed social skills. The stage presentation pushes beyond them into less familiar terrain.

The imposter phenomenon isn’t about you as a person. It’s about the gap between the situation and your experience with similar situations. This distinction matters because it shifts the focus from fixing yourself to understanding your environment.

In The Inner Game of Tennis, Timothy Gallwey identified something crucial about human performance: we all have two distinct systems operating in our heads.

Self 1 is the conscious critic, the voice that provides running commentary on everything you’re doing wrong. Don’t mess this up. Everyone will see you’re not qualified. You should know this by now.

Self 2 is the unconscious performer, the part that actually knows how to do things, learns naturally through experience, and performs best when left alone to execute.

The imposter phenomenon is Self 1 hijacking the show.

It’s your inner critic attempting to protect you by cataloguing all the ways you might fail, all the evidence that you don’t belong, all the gaps in your knowledge that others might notice. But here’s the problem: Self 1’s protective intervention usually makes things worse. The more it talks, the more Self 2 tenses up and loses access to its natural capabilities.

Your internal narrative drives your external performance. If your story is that you don’t belong here, that you’re going to be found out, that everyone else is more qualified, then that’s exactly how you’ll show up — hesitant, defensive, diminished.

But what if the story was different?

What if you told yourself that you’re here because someone saw value in what you bring, that you may not know everything but you know enough to contribute meaningfully, that this uncomfortable feeling is simply evidence of growth in progress?

Same situation. Same person. Completely different performance.

Rather than waiting for confidence to mysteriously appear, we can create the conditions where it’s more likely to emerge.

Preparation moves you up the scale — the more thoroughly you understand what you’re walking into, the higher your baseline confidence.

Your brain’s pattern recognition system also works in your favour. Previous wins in similar situations boost your position because your nervous system remembers that you’ve handled comparable challenges before.

Clear role definition reduces the cognitive load of uncertainty. When you know exactly what’s expected of you, mental resources that would otherwise go toward figuring out the rules can be redirected toward performance.

Support systems matter enormously as well — having backup, whether that’s a mentor you can call or simply knowing your team has your back, fundamentally changes your risk calculus.

Perhaps most importantly, learning to quiet Self 1 allows Self 2 to operate more naturally. This isn’t about positive thinking or affirmations, it’s about reducing the internal interference that prevents your competence from expressing itself.

The next time you notice your confidence is low, resist the urge to label yourself as not a confident person.

Instead, treat it as diagnostic information.

Ask yourself what would move you up the scale in this specific context. What conditions could you create? What evidence do you have from similar situations that you’ve handled before? What preparation would serve you here?

You’re not trying to become confident as a permanent state. You’re learning to operate more effectively wherever you are on the continuum, recognising that your position will shift based on circumstances, preparation, and familiarity.

Low confidence isn’t a character flaw or personal failing. It’s data. It’s information about your preparation level, your familiarity with the situation, or the support systems you have in place.

When you treat it as information rather than identity, you can use that data strategically. You can create better conditions, seek relevant preparation, or adjust your approach to move up the scale.

This shift from confidence as fixed trait to confidence as dynamic response changes everything.

It transforms an insurmountable personal limitation into a manageable situational variable.

And that makes all the difference in how you show up when it matters most.

Until next week,

Chris