Satisficers vs Maximisers

CBChris Bodman7 September 2025 · 5 min read

You know that feeling when you can see the finish line, but somehow never cross it?

The business plan is drafted but not submitted. The course is 90% complete but never finished. The project that could change everything sits in your files, tantalisingly close to done but somehow always needing "just a bit more work."

It's maddening because you're clearly capable. You've proven that by getting this far. You've overcome the hardest parts, solved the complex problems, done the heavy lifting that most people never even attempt.

Yet here you are, stuck in what I call the "almost zone." Close enough to taste success, but not quite willing to reach out and grab it.

This isn't about laziness or lack of ability. Something else is happening here, something more psychologically complex than most people realise.

I've noticed this phenomenon appears most frequently in people who are naturally driven to optimise everything they touch. These are individuals who see possibilities for improvement everywhere they look.

Which sounds like a strength, right?

The mindset that drives exceptional achievement can become the very thing that prevents you from actually achieving it.

Let me explain what I mean.

Research in decision-making has identified two fundamentally different approaches to how people make choices and pursue goals.

The first type are what I’ll refer to as "satisficers." These people establish clear criteria for what counts as success, then stop once they've met that standard. Good enough is genuinely good enough. They complete projects, launch products, and move forward without endless second-guessing.

The second type are "maximisers." They're constantly seeking the absolute best possible outcome. Every decision gets optimised. Every project could theoretically be improved. The question isn't whether something is good enough, but whether it's as good as it could possibly be.

You might be very familiar of this second type and even the experienced the dark side of maximising.

Here's what happens mentally as you approach completion.

Your brain, which has been energised by solving interesting problems throughout the journey, suddenly notices dozens of potential improvements. Details that could be refined. Approaches that could be enhanced. Elements that feel not quite polished enough.

At 50% completion, these observations fuel progress. They give you direction and energy to keep improving.

At 95% completion, they become psychological quicksand.

Because now you're operating under different conditions. Deadlines loom. Other commitments demand attention. The return on investment for each improvement gets smaller while the effort required stays the same.

This creates a type of avoidance. Part of your mind wants to finish and move on. Another part insists on continuing to optimise and improve. These competing drives can create a kind of mental paralysis.

Rather than resolving this tension by pushing through to completion, many people unconsciously choose a third option: postponement.

You tell yourself you need a bit more time to get it right. That it would be irresponsible to rush the final stages. That all the excellent work you've done so far deserves a properly excellent conclusion.

These feel like valid reasons. They are valid reasons. But they often serve as covers for something deeper.

Completion represents a form of mental exposure that many high achievers find uncomfortable.

At 95% done, your potential remains intact. People can see your capability while imagining how brilliant the finished version would be. Your reputation stays protected in the realm of "what if."

At 100% done, your actual work faces real-world judgment. Others will evaluate not your potential, but your execution. Not what you might have accomplished, but what you actually delivered.

This shift from potential to actual creates vulnerability. And for people whose identity is built around being exceptional, vulnerability can feel dangerous.

So the unconscious mind develops what appears to be perfectionist behaviour but functions more like procrastination. By never quite finishing, you never quite risk the full judgment that comes with completion.

The problem is that this protection comes with enormous opportunity costs.

Ideas that could have created value remain unrealised. Goals that could have built momentum stay incomplete. Projects that could have opened doors never quite make it through those doors.

Over time, you start to identify as someone who's great at starting but struggles with finishing. This becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy as your confidence in your ability to complete things erodes.

But here's what's actually happening: you're not bad at finishing. You're protecting yourself from the discomfort of imperfection in high-stakes situations.

Understanding this distinction changes everything about how you approach the solution.

The issue isn't your completion skills. It's your tolerance for putting imperfect work into the world. It's about becoming comfortable with the vulnerability that accompanies finished projects.

Once you recognise this pattern, you can start addressing the real barriers.

Begin by questioning the improvement opportunities that arise late in projects. Ask yourself: "Is this a genuine enhancement that will meaningfully improve the outcome, or am I generating busywork to avoid the discomfort of completion?"

Often, you'll discover that the "critical improvements" you're considering would make minimal difference to the actual impact or reception of your work.

Next, practice setting completion criteria in advance.

Before you start a project, define what "done" looks like. Write it down. When you reach those criteria, you're finished, regardless of what additional improvements you might notice.

This isn't about lowering your standards. It's about distinguishing between perfection and excellence, between theoretical optimisation and practical value creation.

Experiment with external accountability structures. Share deadlines with others. Promise delivery dates to people whose opinions matter to you. Create consequences that make the social cost of not finishing higher than the psychological cost of finishing imperfectly.

Most importantly, reframe what completion means. Instead of seeing it as the end of improvement, view it as the beginning of real-world learning. You cannot optimise based on theoretical feedback. You need actual data from actual users.

The projects you complete at 95% of theoretical perfection will teach you more about what works than the projects you abandon at 95% of actual progress ever could.

Top performers understand something that chronic almost-finishers don't: iteration beats perfection. The person who completes ten good projects will almost always outperform the person who spends the same time perfecting two projects.

Your tendency to see improvements everywhere isn't a flaw. It's a genuine strength. But like any strength, it can become a liability when misapplied.

The goal isn't to stop seeing improvements. It's to develop the judgment to know when pursuing those improvements serves your objectives and when it serves your fears.

Your breakthrough isn't hiding in the next optimisation. It's waiting for you to publish what you've already built.

Until next week,

Chris