Not so SMART

CBChris Bodman1 June 2025 · 3 min read

We’re nearly halfway through the year.

Time to dust off those January goals and see where you stand.

If you’re like most people, those carefully crafted SMART goals feel more like smart criticisms than smart strategies.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth: SMART goals might be sabotaging your long-term progress.

Recent studies with professional athletes have uncovered an important distinction.

Yes, specific goals improve objective performance in the short term. Meta-analyses confirm this.

But they come with hidden costs: higher pressure, reduced enjoyment, and less flow.

Meanwhile, athletes using “open goals” (exploratory, process-focused objectives like “see how fast you can run”) report more frequent flow states, increased confidence, and greater long-term engagement.

The objective performance? Nearly identical.

Picture two golfers:

Golfer A (Fixed Goal): “I need to shoot 68 today.”

Golfer B (Open Goal): “Let’s see how low I can go.”

Golfer A will likely see faster short-term improvements. The specific target creates focus.

But Golfer B builds something more valuable. By staying open to possibilities, they develop awareness, notice what’s working, and adapt naturally to course conditions.

Six months later, Golfer A hits their target and plateaus. Golfer B has developed capabilities that compound.

Here’s what most people miss: the real power lies not in the goal itself but in the person you become whilst pursuing it.

Your goals are vehicles for growth, not just destinations.

When you understand this shift, setbacks become data. Challenges become opportunities. The journey becomes as valuable as the arrival.

But we treat goals like performance contracts. Hit the target or you’ve failed. This binary thinking kills curiosity, experimentation, and intrinsic motivation.

Like with most approaches to bettering performance, context matters.

Consider Fixed Goals When:

  • Competition demands immediate performance
  • You need short-term motivation
  • Clear benchmarks are critical

Consider Open Goals When:

  • You’re learning or developing
  • Pressure is already high
  • Long-term engagement matters more than immediate results

Most of us, in my experience, spend too much time in “fixed goal mode.”

This week, I challenge you to reflect and use this half-year marker to reset, recalibrate, and align your actions to where they need to be.

Step 1: Audit Your Current Goals

Ask:

  • Are these creating pressure or possibility?
  • What would the “open goal” version look like?

Step 2: Design Parallel Tracks

For each major goal, create both versions:

Fixed Goal: “Launch my side project by December”

Open Goal: “Explore how effectively I can help people solve this problem”

Use the fixed goal for planning. Use the open goal to spark curiosity and flow.

Step 3: Choose Your Primary Mode

If you’re in restoration mode after a period of intense work or training, lean into open goals. Focus on exploration and rediscovering joy.

If you’re in a competitive phase, use fixed goals strategically, but balance them with open exploration.

The person who only pursues specific outcomes becomes rigid. The person who only explores never achieves.

The magic happens when you master both.

Start with curiosity. Build capabilities through experimentation. Then channel that potential toward specific targets when needed.

Your goals aren’t just about what you achieve. They’re about who you become in the pursuit.

Until next week,

Chris