For the over-optimiser

CBChris Bodman23 February 2025 · 4 min read

We optimise our lives into algorithms.

Every step, rep, REM cycle compressed into a single, sterile score.

In our relentless pursuit of optimisation, we’ve optimised ourselves right out of being human.

The numbers might improve, but we lose something deeper: enjoyment, artistry, spontaneity.

What if the more we optimise, the more we lose?

We schedule every minute for productivity, forgetting that our best insights often come during unplanned moments of quiet reflection. We seek the latest biohack and supplement while neglecting the fundamentals - movement, sleep, real food, meaningful connections, and rest.

Beware of efficiency, it can be a dangerous road to travel.

The most efficient way to an unfulfilled life is to speed it up until there’s none left.

Sometimes the most optimal thing you can do… is forget about being optimal at all.

I recently spoke with Dan Hyman, whose experience and expertise speak to this tension.

After university, Dan fell into modelling and quickly worked out that success meant getting into underwear-model shape. He studied nutrition, became a qualified PT, and devoured everything he could find about health optimisation.

He achieved his goal, booking the jobs he wanted.

But the optimisation didn’t stop. Life became a spreadsheet of metrics: daily calorie intake, every rep logged, running splits, steps, body fat percentage, sleep data, HRV, jobs booked.

Success on paper. But at what cost?

Dan explained:

“If your health routine is so ‘optimised’ that you start to compromise on what matters, at what point does that constant desire for optimisation become a hindrance? More is not always better. There’s a tipping point.”

Stress management is a fundamental driver of health progression, yet stressing over the 1% might cause more damage than good.

Chris Bumstead, 6x Mr. Olympia, recently spoke about this:

“The stress from trying to be perfect may damage your performance more quickly than the imperfections will.”

This is something we see across all levels of performance.

Look at Will Goodge. After running 55 miles a day across America, he’d crack open a beer with his crew. Not optimal on paper, but exactly what he needed.

The constant drive for optimisation can pull us further from our original goals: feeling good day-to-day, improving health span, and spending quality time with people who matter.

We can create a prison of absolutes:

  • Every moment must be productive
  • Every action must be optimal
  • Every day must be a personal best

The trade off? Humanity. Presence. Joy.

This mindset creates a cascade of daily anxieties:

Your sleep app says you had a bad night? Watch how quickly your mind creates that reality. Your morning routine gets disrupted? Notice how you write off the entire day. Your productivity score dips? Feel the anxiety rise.

We build dependencies on our tools and routines. When life throws chaos our way, and we’re too fixated on being optimal, we lose our ability to adapt.

We’ve optimised ourselves into inflexibility. Created rigid systems instead of resilient ones. Built perfect routines that shatter under pressure.

The truth about performance? It thrives on adaptation, lives in imperfection, and grows through disruption.

Take strength training. I could use AI to create the perfect programme, analysing the best coaches’ methods and spitting out a hyper-optimised plan.

It would obviously work.

The reps, sets, and progression would all be “correct.” But something crucial would be missing:

Being human.

It wouldn’t adapt to how you feel. It wouldn’t account for the unpredictable — bad sleep, stress, or just an off day. It wouldn’t understand the art of training. The intuition, the feedback, the ability to pivot.

That’s the problem with hyper-optimisation. It creates a rigid system that looks perfect but crumbles in reality.

If you’re reading this, you’re likely part of a dangerous subset: The perennial optimisers. The chronic analysers. The perpetual improvers.

You’re already being bombarded with noise, constantly sold on the idea that fitting more in means getting ahead. But for what gain?

The solution isn’t more optimisation. It’s better selection.

Choose what truly matters — the few things worth your optimisation energy. Then have the awareness to spot when this intensity starts leaking into areas that don’t deserve it.

What if your next level of performance isn’t found in more tracking, better data, or tighter systems?

Maybe it’s time to stop optimising everything. And start experiencing something.

Until next week,

Chris

(Thanks to Dan for inspiring and contributing to this week's issue.)


P.S. What areas of your life could you loosen your grip on?

Hit reply - I want to hear instances where you might find more peace by optimising less