This week's newsletter, inspired by a recent conversation with Liam Holmes (Head of Nutrition at Marchon), explores a powerful shift in how to approach lasting change.
As the new year approaches, consider this:
Your worst days in 2025 will matter more than your best.
Let me explain.
Your brain isn't designed for transformation — it's wired for survival. It conserves energy by creating shortcuts, automating decisions, and falling back on familiar patterns. That's not a flaw, it's a feature.
As January nears, we're particularly drawn to setting ambitious targets and reaching new heights. We define ourselves by personal bests and judge our progress against what we've done before.
In fitness, we track our fastest runs. In nutrition, we remember our most disciplined weeks. In life, we measure ourselves against our brightest moments.
But there's a fundamental flaw in this ceiling-focused approach.
Think of your brain as a river that carves its path. It will always seek the route of least resistance, flowing naturally toward what's easy, comfortable, and familiar.
Fighting this flow with willpower alone is the reason 90% of New Year resolutions fail by the end of January.
Instead, consider a different approach to lasting change: raising your baseline.
When we study consistent performers, from Olympic athletes to high-performing professionals, we notice something surprising.
Their success isn't built on extreme habits or iron-clad willpower. You won't find all of them following rigid morning routines or incessant regimens.
Instead, they've mastered something far more powerful: elevating their default state. Their progress comes from incremental improvements, stacked day by day.
From a nutrition perspective, this becomes painfully clear. When life intensifies, when stress mounts, when energy depletes – that's when your true baseline reveals itself.
Your baseline is the sum of your unconscious choices:
The meals you eat when exhausted
The habits you maintain when stressed
The decisions you make when overwhelmed
It's what you do on autopilot when life gets real.
The Tale of Two Approaches
Let's look at how this plays out in real life through two common scenarios:
Scenario A (Raising the Ceiling)
Monday: Perfect diet, 1-hour workout
Tuesday: Perfect diet, 1-hour workout
Wednesday: Stressed, skipped meals and snacked too much
Thursday: Skipped workout and ordered a takeaway
Friday-Sunday: Complete collapse, back to old habits
Scenario B (Raising the Floor)
Monday: Added one vegetable to dinner
Tuesday: Maintained vegetable intake at dinner plus took stairs instead of elevator
Wednesday: Stressed, but still had prepped lunch
Thursday: Tired, but got most of the planned training session done
Friday-Sunday: Not perfect, but maintained basic habits
When you try to maintain perfect habits, you're fighting against your brain's operating system.
But when you gradually raise your baseline, you're rewiring your neural pathways to make better choices the default option.
It might not make for dramatic transformations or match the highlight reels we see, but it's the change that actually lasts.
Consider the difference between these two mindsets:
Ceiling Mindset
Relies on motivation and willpower
Creates unsustainable pressure
Leads to all-or-nothing thinking
Results in cyclical failure patterns
Damages self-trust over time
Baseline Mindset
Works with your brain's natural tendencies
Builds sustainable momentum
Allows for flexibility and recovery
Creates compound improvements
Strengthens self-trust through consistency
The Practical Application
Here's how to raise your baseline for the year ahead:
Identify Your Current Baseline
What do you actually do on your worst days?
What habits persist even when you're stressed?
What choices feel effortless right now?
Design Minimal Viable Improvements
What's one small step up from your current worst?
What could you do even on your most challenging day?
What feels almost too easy to count as progress?
Focus on Consistency Over Intensity
Can you maintain this for a month straight?
Would you be willing to do this even when unmotivated?
Does this feel sustainable long-term?
The compound effect of this approach is powerful.
A 1% improvement in your baseline might seem trivial. But over time, your worst days surpass what used to be your average.
Yesterday's ceiling becomes tomorrow's floor, creating a foundation for even greater possibilities.
The most powerful transformations aren't found in perfect weeks or dramatic breakthroughs. They're built in the space between intention and consistency, where daily choices gradually reshape who you become.
It's better to be consistently good, than occasionally great. — Nick Bare
The Environment Factor
Your environment will always win against willpower. The key is to design your surroundings to make your baseline behaviours the path of least resistance:
Keep healthy snacks within reach
Remove or limit the opportunity for bad choices
Set up your environments for adherence by default (e.g. food shopping on a full stomach)
Create systems that make good choices easier than bad ones
Life doesn't test your ceiling — it tests your floor. When stress hits, deadlines loom, or crisis strikes, you won't rise to the level of your aspirations.
You'll fall to the level of your baseline.
The question isn't "How good can your best days be?"
It's "How good are your worst days?"
Make that baseline worth falling to.
As we close out 2024, thank you for your continued support. Here's to raising your baseline in 2025,